Could This Sweet Backsplash Style Replace Subway Tile In Your Kitchen?
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

TL;DR

Chip and Joanna Gaines used chocolate-colored, patterned clay tiles in the game-room kitchen of their Colorado mountain home. The design offers one example of a warmer backsplash style, but it does not establish that subway tile is no longer popular or that the alternative will suit every kitchen or budget.

Chip and Joanna Gaines chose chocolate-colored patterned clay tiles rather than subway tile for the game-room kitchen in their Colorado mountain home, presenting a warmer backsplash option suited to the setting. The choice, shown in Fixer Upper: Colorado Mountain House—Part 2 and described on Magnolia’s blog, is a design example—not evidence that subway tile has broadly fallen out of favor.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

The tiles are Tiles of Ezra Amano Caja in chocolate, with an ivory background and light-brown geometric details. The Magnolia blog says the design was meant to reflect the Rocky Mountains and “specifically blend with the surroundings.” The kitchen is part of a game room and includes a “hot cocoa, coffee bar,” according to the episode.

The Colorado renovation was the couple’s first makeover away from Texas, the blog says. Rather than relying on the modern farmhouse look associated with their previous projects, they drew on “European cottage-inspired colors, textures, and patterns” to create what the blog describes as a cozy feel. Those details help explain why the patterned tiles were selected for this particular home.

The style draws on Delft-inspired patterning and the current interest in artisan tiles, which are valued by some homeowners for visible craftsmanship and irregularities. The design advice accompanying the project suggests pairing patterned tile with wood, complementary stone, warm cream tones, rustic-finish hardware and accessories. Those are styling suggestions, not requirements or proof that a particular combination will work in every kitchen.

At a glance
reportWhen: Featured in Fixer Upper: Colorado Mount…
The developmentA Magnolia feature and Fixer Upper episode show Chip and Joanna Gaines using chocolate-patterned clay tiles instead of subway tile in a Colorado mountain-home kitchen.
Kitchen Design · Briefing

A warmer backsplash option for one Colorado kitchen

Chip and Joanna Gaines used chocolate-patterned clay tile in their Colorado mountain home. The project shows one design choice, not a shift in subway tile’s popularity.

Up to $1,500
stated average installation cost
November 2026
article update

The tile and its setting

The patterned surface was chosen to reflect the Rocky Mountains and blend with the surroundings.

Material

Amano Caja in chocolate

Tiles of Ezra clay tile with an ivory background and light-brown geometric details.

Room

A game-room kitchen

The space includes a hot cocoa and coffee bar in the Colorado mountain home.

A broader design direction

The renovation paired the backsplash with a cottage-inspired palette and textures.

Design cues
  • European cottage-inspired colors and patterns
  • Warm cream tones, wood and complementary stone
  • Rustic-finish hardware and accessories
Other ideas mentioned
  • Red Barrel Studio peel-and-stick wallpaper
  • White square tiles painted and baked as a DIY project
  • These are different materials and require checking product directions

What the example can tell you

It offers inspiration for a particular setting, not proof that one backsplash suits every kitchen.

1
Compare samples

Check patterned tiles against your cabinets, counters and lighting.

2
Get local estimates

Separate material and labor costs; the stated average is not a project quote.

3
Check practical fit

Ask about cleaning, sealing, durability and suitability for the location.

WatchNo sales data or survey is provided to show that subway tile has broadly fallen out of favor.
The takeaway
Patterned clay tile can bring warmth and character to a kitchen, but the right choice depends on your design, budget and practical needs.

A Warmer Alternative to Subway Tile

The Gaineses’ project illustrates how a backsplash can help set the atmosphere of a kitchen, especially when the space also serves as a place to gather. A patterned, warm-toned surface may feel more connected to a mountain or cottage-inspired interior than a simple glossy white tile. For readers planning a renovation, the example offers a specific direction to explore: color, pattern and handmade character can make the backsplash a defining part of the room rather than a neutral background.

That does not mean subway tile is objectively outdated or that homeowners should replace it. The claim that the style has “lost its appeal” is an editorial judgment in the original coverage, not a finding supported by market data or a survey. The practical decision depends on a home’s design, the owner’s preferences, maintenance needs and project costs. The Gaineses’ choice matters as a visible design example, not as a verdict on all kitchens.

Cost is part of the trade-off. The article says backsplash installation can average up to $1,500, while handcrafted tiles can add expense. That figure is a broad estimate, not a quote for this project, and no tile quantity, labor breakdown or regional pricing is provided. Readers should compare local estimates and material costs before treating it as a budget forecast.

Products Worth Considering

Google Nest Learning Thermostat (4th Gen, 2024) with Nest Temperature Sensor, Polished Gold

Google Nest Learning Thermostat (4th Gen, 2024) with Nest Temperature Sensor, Polished Gold

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

The Colorado Home’s Design Direction

The renovation, featured in Fixer Upper: Colorado Mountain House—Part 2, moved the Gaineses beyond their familiar Texas projects. Magnolia’s account says the design team used colors, textures and patterns inspired by a European cottage aesthetic and the surrounding landscape. The backsplash was one part of that broader approach, alongside a cooking area described as using maroon, cream and granite tones.

The article also points to small details that can make a room feel personal, including retro-looking appliances and a small piece of artwork. These ideas are presented as ways to complement the tile rather than as confirmed features required for the look. The central design choice remains the ivory-and-brown patterned clay tile installed in the game-room kitchen.

For less expensive or hands-on alternatives, the article names Red Barrel Studio’s Brooklyn Delft Ivy peel-and-stick wallpaper and describes a DIY approach: buying white square tiles and porcelain paint, then painting and baking the tiles. These options are not equivalent to the installed Tiles of Ezra product. The peel-and-stick item is wallpaper, while painted ceramic tiles require the maker to complete the finishing and installation work.

““specifically blend with the surroundings””

— Magnolia blog post

Popularity, Pricing and Practical Fit

The available account does not provide sales figures, designer surveys or other evidence that subway tile is losing popularity across kitchens. It also does not identify the tile’s price, the amount installed, the installation cost for the Colorado project or how the material performs under everyday kitchen use. The stated installation average of up to $1,500 has no geographic or project-specific breakdown.

It is also unclear whether the named peel-and-stick wallpaper is intended for the exact same conditions as a conventional backsplash, or what cleaning and durability limitations apply. The DIY tile method requires painting, baking and installing tiles, but no detailed instructions or safety guidance are provided. Homeowners should check product directions and consult qualified installers when needed rather than assume every alternative is suitable for a cooking area.

Compare Materials Before Renovating

No further project announcement or follow-up about the Colorado kitchen is included in the account. For homeowners considering a similar look, the next step is to compare tile samples with their cabinets, counters and lighting, then request local estimates that separate material and labor costs. Ask installers about cleaning, sealing, durability and suitability for the intended location.

Anyone considering painted or peel-and-stick alternatives should check the maker’s product instructions, especially for placement near heat, water and food-preparation areas. The Gaineses’ renovation shows one way to use patterned clay tile in a specific setting; whether it replaces subway tile in another kitchen remains a matter of design preference and project requirements.

Source: rss

Key Questions

What backsplash tiles did Chip and Joanna Gaines use?

They used Tiles of Ezra Amano Caja in chocolate, with an ivory base and light-brown geometric patterning, in the game-room kitchen of their Colorado mountain home.

Does this project prove subway tile is out of style?

No. It documents one design choice, but provides no survey or market data showing that subway tile has broadly lost popularity. The claim that it has fallen out of favor is an editorial opinion.

How much can a backsplash installation cost?

The article gives an average of up to $1,500 for backsplash installation and says handcrafted tiles can add expense. It does not specify the location, project size or what the estimate includes, so local quotes may differ.

Are there lower-cost ways to try a patterned backsplash?

The article suggests Red Barrel Studio’s Brooklyn Delft Ivy peel-and-stick wallpaper and describes painting white square tiles with porcelain paint. These are different products and methods; check manufacturer instructions and suitability for the kitchen location before buying or installing them.

Source: hunker.com

You May Also Like

Black, Bold Cabinets And Dramatic Green Tiles Refresh This 2000S Kitchen

A DIY renovation updates a dated kitchen with black cabinets and dramatic green tiles, creating a stylish, personalized space at a fraction of the cost.

These Gorgeous Galley Kitchens Prove You Don’t Need Square Footage To Have An Amazing Cook Space

Veranda highlights 15 galley kitchens that use light, storage, color and seating to make compact cooking spaces feel distinctive and useful.

Could These 10 Kitchen Trends Make Your Home Look Dated Later?

A headline-only report flags 10 kitchen trends that may age poorly, but provides no list, evidence or expert comments to verify the claim.

Flexible Lifestyle Dining Menus

Restaurants are increasingly adopting flexible dining menus to cater to diverse lifestyles, offering customizable options for health, dietary needs, and convenience.